News
Tawakkol Karman: Spreading Fear Is a Dictator’s Way of Controlling the Narrative
The New York Times columnist Thomas L. Friedman has highlighted the experience of human rights advocate and Nobel Peace Prize laureate Tawakkol Karman in a column examining what her struggle against authoritarian rule can teach Americans about defending democracy.
In his article, “Two Democracy Heroes on America,” Friedman reflects on his conversations with two democracy activists from the Middle East, Karman and Palestinian activist Samer Sinijlawi. He contrasts what he describes as two political “allergies”: performative activism that consists largely of online slogans, and passivity when democracy itself is at risk. He writes that both activists have taken significant personal risks in defending the right to free and fair elections, and are troubled by what they see as the willingness of many Americans to remain on the sidelines as democratic norms come under pressure.
Introducing Karman, Friedman notes her leading role in Yemen’s peaceful 2011 uprising and her distinction as the first Yemeni and first Arab woman to receive the Nobel Peace Prize for her nonviolent leadership of protests demanding democracy, women’s rights and freedom of speech.
Speaking with Friedman over coffee at the Athens Democracy Forum, Karman said she was shocked by how readily American law firms, universities and even some media companies had accommodated President Donald Trump’s political demands without fighting back.
Drawing on her experience opposing dictatorship in Yemen, Karman explained that authoritarianism begins when a head of state gains control over the media, accuses it of lying and discredits it, while abandoning the rule of law and turning state institutions toward serving the leader and his family.
She pointed to Yemen under Saleh as a warning. According to Karman, the trigger for Yemen’s democratic revolution came when Saleh placed his son and family members in the most important state institutions. She recalled that he attacked the judiciary and stripped it of its role, escaped accountability through immunity, and interfered in the work of Parliament and other legitimate institutions.
“And now all of this I am seeing in the United States. What is that?” she asked.
For Karman, however, the most dangerous stage in the erosion of democracy comes when fear begins to shape people's behavior from within.
She said the warning sign is when people begin asking themselves: “If I do this, what will happen to me? What will the leader do to me?” Whether they are journalists, students or teachers, she explained, people begin questioning themselves before speaking or acting.
“That is what the dictator wants — to spread fear,” Karman said.
She argued that when lawyers stop doing their work, journalists stop doing theirs, scholars withdraw, and people begin watching themselves before saying or doing anything, fear becomes an instrument of authoritarian control. In her words, this is “the dictator’s way to control the narrative.”
Yet Karman has not lost hope in America.
Friedman recounts her describing a speech she gave in North Dakota, where she encountered many conservative Americans who welcomed her warmly. Karman told them not to assume that Americans are divided because division is somehow inherent to them. Rather, she argued, people can be deliberately divided through hate speech.
The response, Friedman writes, was deeply emotional.
Friedman also notes that he first met Karman in Sana’a in 2013, when he traveled to Yemen to observe the country’s broad-based National Dialogue, in which new political parties, young people and women participated.
Karman’s message, as presented by Friedman, is ultimately a warning drawn from experience: democratic institutions do not collapse only when they are formally abolished. They can be weakened when independent institutions stop resisting political pressure, when professionals begin to self-censor, and when fear persuades citizens to police themselves.
Her experience in Yemen, Friedman suggests, offers Americans a powerful reminder that democracy depends not only on institutions existing on paper, but on the willingness of the people within those institutions—and citizens outside them—to defend their independence and refuse to surrender to fear.
Read the full article in Arabic [here]
Read Thomas L. Friedman’s column in The New York Times [here].
